Gastonia, February 18, 2026
The Gastonia City Council is considering a significant proposal that would limit the mayor’s voting power to only tie-breaking situations. Currently, the mayor can vote on all issues, a privilege only shared with one other city in North Carolina. The proposal has sparked a debate on the balance between the mayor’s duties and effective governance, with council members divided on the issue. Proponents argue the change would align Gastonia with state standards, while the mayor contends it undermines his role.
Gastonia
City Council Deliberates Limiting Mayor’s Voting Authority
The Gastonia City Council on Tuesday evening considered a significant proposal to amend its city charter, a change that would restrict the mayor’s voting power to solely tie-breaking situations. This potential amendment has the capacity to reshape the operational dynamics and governance within the council.
Currently, the mayor possesses the authority to cast a vote on any issue that comes before the council. This broad voting right places Gastonia as one of only two cities in North Carolina where the mayor holds such an extensive voting privilege on all council actions. The deliberation on this proposed change marks a pivotal moment for the city’s local governance.
Differing Views on Mayoral Responsibilities and Council Efficiency
The proposal has sparked considerable discussion among council members, reflecting differing philosophies on the mayor’s role. Councilwoman Donyel Barber, who supports the proposed change, highlighted that historically, mayors in Gastonia typically exercised their vote only when there was a need to break a tie. She indicated that balancing the mayor’s primary duties of presiding over meetings and ensuring their smooth conduct can be challenging when simultaneously participating in every vote. Barber also raised concerns about consistency, noting instances where the mayor chose not to vote, leading to questions about the predictable application of this voting authority.
Conversely, Mayor Richard Franks has voiced strong opposition to the suggested limitation. He views the proposal as an attempt to relegate his position to that of a “figurehead,” which he believes would impede his effectiveness in serving the citizens of Gastonia. Mayor Franks argued that if his voting authority is to be re-evaluated, the council should also examine other aspects of the mayor’s role that he considers limited, such as the ability to set the council agenda. He pointed out that in other municipalities within Gaston County, mayors typically have the responsibility of setting the agenda, a function currently performed by the city manager in Gastonia.
Understanding Mayoral Powers: Gastonia within State Context
The discussion in Gastonia takes place within the broader framework of mayoral powers as defined by North Carolina state law and individual city charters. Under North Carolina General Statutes (G.S. 160A-69), mayors throughout the state are generally granted the right to vote primarily in instances where a tie needs to be broken. However, this general rule can be altered by specific provisions within a city’s charter, which can delineate different voting rules for its mayor. For mayors who are directly elected by the public and whose city charters restrict their vote to tie-breaking situations, there is no legal obligation to cast a tie-breaking vote; if the mayor chooses not to vote, the tied motion fails. This differs from city council members in North Carolina, who generally have a legal duty to vote on most matters unless they are excused for specific, legally defined reasons, such as a direct financial conflict of interest.
The current City of Gastonia charter, specifically Section 2.3, states that the mayor “has the right to vote on all matters before the Council.” While it also notes the mayor “is not required to vote except when the Mayor’s vote is necessary for determinative action,” and that a failure to vote when required is recorded as an affirmative vote, the core right to vote on all matters is explicitly stated. The proposed amendment aims to narrow this existing broader right, bringing Gastonia’s mayoral voting power more in line with the general state standard of tie-breaking votes.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Gastonia City Council considering?
The Gastonia City Council on Tuesday evening considered a significant proposal to amend its city charter, a change that would restrict the mayor’s voting power to solely tie-breaking situations.
What is the current voting power of the Gastonia mayor?
Currently, the mayor possesses the authority to cast a vote on any issue that comes before the council. The City of Gastonia’s charter, specifically Section 2.3, states that the mayor “has the right to vote on all matters before the Council.”
Why is this change being proposed?
Councilwoman Donyel Barber, a proponent of the change, highlighted that past mayors in Gastonia typically exercised their vote only when a tie needed to be broken. She suggested that the mayor’s primary duties of presiding over meetings and ensuring their smooth conduct can be challenging to balance with voting on all issues. Barber also raised concerns about consistency, noting instances where the mayor opted not to vote, which raised questions about the predictable application of this voting authority.
What is the Mayor’s stance on the proposal?
Mayor Richard Franks has voiced strong opposition to the suggested limitation. He views the proposal as an attempt to relegate his position to that of a “figurehead,” which he believes would impede his effectiveness in serving the citizens of Gastonia.
How do mayoral voting powers compare in other North Carolina cities?
Gastonia is notable for being one of only two cities in North Carolina where the mayor holds such an extensive voting privilege on all council actions. Under North Carolina General Statutes (G.S. 160A-69), mayors throughout the state are generally granted the right to vote primarily in instances where a tie needs to be broken.
Key Features of the Gastonia Mayoral Voting Power Proposal
| Feature | Current Situation | Proposed Change | Scope |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mayor’s Voting Power | Can vote on any issue before the council. | Limited to voting only in tie-breaking situations. | Local (Gastonia) |
| Comparison to Most North Carolina Cities | One of only two cities in North Carolina where the mayor can vote on every action. | Would align more closely with the general North Carolina standard where mayors primarily vote to break ties. | State-level |
| Agenda Setting Authority | Currently the responsibility of the city manager. | Mayor Franks suggests this role should also be reviewed and potentially transferred to the mayor, as in other municipalities within the county. | Local (Gastonia) and County-level comparison |
| Historical Precedent (Gastonia) | Previous mayors typically voted only to break ties. | The proposed change would formalize a past practice. | Local (Gastonia) |
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Author: HERE Charlotte
The CHARLOTTE STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HERECharlotte.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in Charlotte, Mecklenburg County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as Lovin' Life Music Festival, Charlotte Pride festival, and major sporting tournaments at Bank of America Stadium. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the Charlotte Regional Business Alliance and Foundation for the Carolinas, plus leading businesses in finance and entertainment that power the local economy such as Bank of America and NASCAR. As part of the broader HERE network, including HEREAsheville.com, HEREGreensboro.com, HERERaleigh.com, and HEREOBX.com, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into North Carolina's dynamic landscape.
